…
Ah, SEO audits. Those wonderfully alarming little reports that arrive with phrases such as: “CRITICAL ISSUE!” “NOT IDEAL!” “ACTION REQUIRED!” And suddenly you’re looking at your perfectly functioning website wondering whether you’ve accidentally committed a serious crime against Google. I’ve had a few conversations recently where another SEO company has analysed one of my clients’ websites and produced a list of things they apparently should be doing differently. Some of the recommendations were perfectly reasonable. Others? Well… Let’s just say I reached for the kettle.
Because there is a very important lesson here: Not every SEO recommendation is an SEO emergency. And not every box left unticked in an automated audit is costing you customers.
The H1 Panic
One of the recommendations was this: “The homepage has three H1 tags, which is not ideal. Each page should have a single H1 heading that clearly signals its main topic to both users and search engines.” Sounds convincing, doesn’t it? Very technical. Very authoritative. And technically, yes, heading structure should be logical.
But here’s the bit that’s missing: Google doesn’t require every page to have exactly one H1. The idea that having three H1s automatically damages your SEO is an outdated oversimplification. Heading tags exist primarily to create structure.
Think of them like the contents of a document:
H1 = main subject
H2 = major sections
H3 = subsections
Paragraph text = the actual information
That’s useful for people reading the page, screen readers interpreting the content and search engines understanding the structure. But Google isn’t sitting there with a clipboard saying: “One H1? Excellent. Two H1s? Straight to page two.” Context matters.
So Why Did I Change Them?
Here’s where it gets interesting. I actually changed the headings. Not because I believed the website had suddenly developed an SEO crisis. I changed them because, having looked at the page, I could improve the hierarchy and formatting (Plus the customer is always right…) Two of the headings were changed to H2 and H3, and the visual styling was adjusted accordingly. One had also been suffering from a rather spectacular white text on a white background situation. Which, regardless of SEO, isn’t particularly helpful to anyone trying to read it.
So yes, I fixed it. But there’s a difference between: “I can improve this.” and “This is damaging your SEO.” Those are not the same statement.
SEO Isn’t a Game of Technical Bingo
This is one of my biggest frustrations with SEO. There are so many things you can measure that it’s tempting to believe everything you measure must be important. It isn’t.
You can run a website through an audit tool and get a lovely list of:
- Missing headings
- Image issues
- Meta data warnings
- Word count recommendations
- Broken links
- Schema suggestions
- Performance scores
- Keyword density
- Technical errors
And then you can spend three days fixing everything. Congratulations. You’ve got a very tidy audit report. But did your website become more useful? Did your customers understand what you do better? Did enquiries increase? Did your rankings improve? That’s the bit I’d be interested in.
Code Isn’t The Same As Content
This is particularly important when someone is analysing the code of a website. Yes, the underlying code matters. Yes, technical SEO matters. Yes, heading structure matters. But search engines don’t understand a business solely because the HTML is beautifully arranged. They need context. They look at the content, the relationships between pages, the site’s relevance, the information provided, links, structured data where appropriate, the overall experience and countless other signals. You cannot “SEO” a website into success by rearranging tags while ignoring what the website actually says.
Fix The Things That Matter
This is where experience comes in. A good SEO professional should be able to distinguish between:
Something that is genuinely broken.
Something that could be improved.
Something that is technically imperfect but insignificant.
And:
Something that simply makes an automated SEO tool unhappy.
Those aren’t interchangeable.
If a website has a broken canonical tag, pages that can’t be indexed, dreadful mobile usability or important content hidden from search engines, I’m interested. If a heading could technically be an H2 instead of an H1? I’ll consider it. But I’m not going to terrify a client into thinking their entire SEO strategy has collapsed because their homepage contains three H1 tags.
Beware The “Grass Is Greener” Pitch
This is where I think businesses need to be particularly careful when another agency approaches them. An SEO audit can be incredibly useful. But it’s also an extremely easy way to create a list of problems. Tell someone their website has 37 issues and you’ve immediately created a sense that something is wrong. Then, conveniently, someone is available to fix those 37 issues for you. That’s not necessarily dishonest. Sometimes there genuinely are 37 things worth fixing. But sometimes there are three important things, fourteen minor things and twenty things that really don’t deserve your attention yet. The skill is knowing the difference.
SEO Is About Priorities
This is the bit I wish more businesses were told. You don’t have an unlimited SEO budget. You don’t have unlimited time. And your website doesn’t need to be technically perfect in every single measurable category before it can rank. Prioritise. Fix genuine problems. Improve useful content. Make the website easy for people to navigate. Make sure search engines can crawl and understand it. Build relevant authority. Keep information current. And continually improve. That’s SEO. Not chasing every red warning icon an audit tool can produce.
I actually like SEO audits. They’re useful. They can highlight things I’ve missed, give me another perspective and occasionally point towards something that genuinely needs fixing. But an audit is a starting point for investigation, not a list of commandments handed down from Google Mountain. If somebody tells you: “You have three H1 tags (on the Homepage), therefore your SEO is wrong.” Ask them: “And what impact is that actually having on my website?” If the answer is simply: “Well… the report says it’s not ideal…” I’d probably put the kettle on. Because good SEO isn’t about making a website score 100% on somebody else’s checklist. It’s about making the website findable, understandable, useful and relevant to the people you’re trying to reach.
And sometimes that means fixing the H1. Sometimes it means fixing the white-on-white text. And sometimes it means leaving the perfectly harmless bit of code alone and spending your time doing something that might actually make a difference.
