…
I’ve been asked this question more than once. “I’ve noticed that whenever I add new products to my website, I seem to get an order. How does that work then?” Excellent question. And, despite what you might expect from someone who spends a lot of time talking about analytics, algorithms, SEO and Google…
I think it’s probably Website Karma. Well, perhaps not entirely. But I’m certainly not convinced that Google is sitting there watching you upload a new product and immediately sending a customer your way as a reward. Wouldn’t that be nice?
The Timing Is Suspicious…
This is something I see with clients all the time. They update the website. They publish a new product. They send a Mailchimp campaign. They add a new event. They publish a blog post. And then… PING. An enquiry arrives. Or an order comes through. And naturally, the first thought is: “Aha! It worked!” Maybe. But possibly not in the way you think.
Let’s Talk About Google
If you’ve just added a brand-new product to your website, you can’t necessarily assume that Google already knows about it. Google needs to discover the page, crawl it, process the information and potentially index it before that page can appear in its organic search results. There isn’t a magic little Google bell that rings the second you press “Publish”. And crawling and indexing aren’t guaranteed to happen on a fixed timetable either. Some pages may be discovered quickly. Others can take considerably longer. So if you’ve added a product this morning and somebody orders it this afternoon, there’s a good chance they haven’t found it through a brand-new Google organic listing. Especially if the product is completely new and hasn’t previously existed on the website.
So Where Did The Customer Come From?
This is where things get interesting. They might already have known about you. They might have visited your website previously. They might have followed you on social media. They might have seen an email. They might have searched for your business rather than the new product. They might have clicked an advert. They might have been talking about your business to somebody else. They might have had your website bookmarked. Or they might simply have been thinking about buying something from you anyway. Then you’ve updated your website… And the timing happens to line up. Karma.
The Mailchimp Effect
I see this particularly clearly with email marketing. A client sends a Mailchimp campaign. Five minutes later: Website enquiry. Cue: “The newsletter worked!” Possibly. But here’s the interesting thing. It might not be because the recipient clicked the exact button in the email. They might have seen the email, thought: “Oh yes, I must get around to that.” Then carried on with their day. Later, they remember the business. They Google it. They visit the website directly. They make a phone call. They buy something. The marketing activity may have triggered the action without being the final measurable click. That’s why marketing attribution can be surprisingly complicated. People aren’t robots.
And Then There Are Blog Posts
Blog posts are slightly different. A useful new blog post can potentially be discovered through search relatively quickly, particularly if the site is regularly crawled and the content is relevant to something people are searching for. But again, there’s no guarantee. And if someone finds your new blog post through Google, that doesn’t necessarily mean Google was responsible for the eventual enquiry either. They might read it, leave, remember you and come back three days later. The customer journey isn’t always: Google → Website → Buy. It’s often: See you somewhere → forget about you → see you again → Google you → read something → go away → remember you → come back → buy. Welcome to marketing.
The Psychology Of “Doing Something”
There’s another possibility that I think gets overlooked. When you update your website, you are doing something. You might then mention the new product on social media. You might tell somebody about it. You might send an email. You might talk about it to a customer. You might photograph it. You might write about it. Your business becomes more visible because you’ve started actively marketing again.
So perhaps the website update isn’t directly responsible for the sale. Perhaps it was the thing that got you moving. And that’s still valuable.
This Is Why I Don’t Promise Magic
SEO isn’t magic. Analytics isn’t magic. Google isn’t magic. And adding a product to your website certainly isn’t a guaranteed sales trigger. But consistency does matter. Keeping your website current gives people more reasons to visit. Creating useful content gives search engines more information about your business. Email marketing gives existing contacts a reason to come back. Social media keeps you visible. New products give you something to talk about. And all of these things work together. Sometimes the result is immediate. Sometimes it takes months. Sometimes you never know exactly which little thing tipped somebody over into becoming a customer.
So… Is Website Karma Real?
I’m going to say yes. Officially, there is no Google ranking factor called Website Karma. I’ve checked. Probably. But I’ve seen enough suspiciously well-timed enquiries to believe there is something going on. Not magic. Not an algorithm secretly rewarding you for updating your product catalogue. And not necessarily SEO. It’s more likely that your marketing activity, customer awareness, existing visibility and a healthy dose of coincidence are all colliding at exactly the right moment. And honestly? I’ll take it. Because if updating your website makes you feel like you’re finally doing something productive with your marketing… And then an order lands in your inbox… Don’t overthink it. Take the win. Thank Website Karma. And update the website again tomorrow.

