blogging-4812375_1920 - Substack essay site blogging WP

(Especially If I Have a Website Already?)

If you’ve spent any time in the online content world lately, you’ve probably heard of Substack. It’s
that thing writers, journalists, podcasters, bloggers and thought leaders keep raving about as a way to publish directly to their audience. But what exactly is it? And if you already have a website (especially one built in WordPress), do you really need to jump on the Substack bandwagon? Let’s break it down.

 

What is Substack?

Substack is essentially a newsletter platform with a built-in “audience model”. Instead of just posting your content on a blog and hoping people visit (to then convert that into business and / or to have sidebar ads running as per older days 2014), you send your content directly to their inboxes (so it’s about getting “subscribers”). It combines blogging, email marketing, and “monetisation” tools into one system. Creators can publish for free or charge a subscription fee for “premium content”.

In short: It’s a publishing platform that helps writers get paid for their work without dealing with ads or complex monetisation schemes / websites etc.

 

How Does It Compare to a WordPress Website?

As a website designer and freelance digital marketer, I always encourage people to own their online presence. A WordPress website gives you control—over branding, SEO / Google Search, content organisation, your business / organisation practices, and how you interact with your audience.

Substack, on the other hand, is a closed ecosystem (so you end up duplicating elsewhere anyway!!). You don’t control how it operates, and if they ever change their terms, you’re at their mercy (kind of like how Facebook pages or Etsy used to be great for organic reach… until they weren’t). That said, Substack does have some perks that make it appealing, especially for writers who want to focus purely on content creation.

 

The Pros and Cons of Substack

substack essay site pros cons

So, Should You Have a Substack?

If you already have a website, the question is whether Substack would complement it or replace part of what you do. Here’s my take:

Use Substack if:

You primarily write essays (author??), opinion pieces, or long-form content and want to focus on building a numbers driven / email-driven >> traffic from subscribers audience – Kind of like a popularity contest.

You want a no-fuss way to monetise your writing through “paid subscriptions”.

You don’t want to deal with website maintenance, hosting, or design.

 

Stick with WordPress if:

Your website is central to your business (e.g., if you offer services, sell products, or rely on SEO traffic).

You need full control over branding, design, and content organisation.

You’re already managing email marketing through a platform like MailChimp.

Also are you going to keep up with another platform or are you just suffering at the hands of Shiny Object Syndrome?

 

Best of Both Worlds?

You can integrate Substack with your existing WordPress site. Some people use Substack purely for their newsletter but link back to their website for deeper content and lead generation / blog posts – We’re still looking into re-using content so as not to encroach to duplicate content. Think of Substack as an extension of your content strategy rather than a full-on replacement.

 

Final Verdict

Substack is great for writers who want to be read without worrying about the technical side of running a site. But if you’re a freelancer, business owner, or marketer, your WordPress website is still your most valuable online asset. Instead of jumping ship, consider whether Substack could serve as an additional marketing tool rather than a full website alternative (and are you just doubling your workload with having both??).

What’s your take? Would you use Substack alongside your website, or are you sticking to your own turf?